$4.75M Sag Harbor Craftsman-style home has an Old Hollywood vibe

$4.75M Sag Harbor Craftsman-style home has an Old Hollywood vibe

May 12, 2025

Interior photos by Shannon Dupre; Aerial photo courtesy of Rise Media.

Even after a renovation by AD100 designer Neal Beckstedt and the influence of design pioneer Joe D’Urso, the house at 12 North Haven Way in Sag Harbor has the air of an early 20th-century estate in the Hollywood Hills. Draped in moss and designed in the Modern Craftsman style, the house sits on four wooded acres, surrounded by manicured hedges, and accessorized by a gunite pool. Asking $4,750,000, it’s as true to its spare but aesthetically rich style inside as out.

Early modern accents like terra cotta floor tile, arched doorways, and exposed wooden beams frame the open rooms, accented by dramatic dark tones that contrast with the bright white plaster walls.

The well-designed kitchen, inspired by the iconic Los Angeles Schindler House, features a commercial-style range, Gaggenau appliances, double dishwashers, and Sapele mahogany custom millwork. Carrara marble worktops were salvaged from New York City’s Plaza Hotel.

A dining room off the kitchen is light-filled and clean. Built-in shelving of rough-hewn wood gives display items pride of place. Also adjacent to the kitchen is a tasting room and wine cellar that could easily double as a pantry.

A glass door rolls open to reveal a private courtyard. The outdoor dining terrace has a dedicated gas grill hook-up.

Of the home’s four bedrooms, three are set up as primary suites. In its own private wing, the main floor suite includes a kitchenette, a dining nook, and a sitting area made cozy by a Swedish wood stove.

The upstairs primary suite is accented by a wood-burning fireplace. A luxuriously modern bathroom gets a Heath tile-lined steam shower accented with Heath tile. A spa nook with a copper soaking tub opens onto a private outdoor terrace.

The third bedroom suite includes a lounge area with an additional fireplace. On the home’s finished third level is space for an artist’s studio with 360-degree viewsโ€“or an opportunity for additional storage.

The 4,000-square-foot home has a one-car garage and a 65-foot-long heated gunite pool and spa, surrounded by verdant landscaped gardens. The exclusive North Haven Point enclave includes private beach access and tennis.

[Listing details: 12 North Haven Way by Kyle Barisich and Jack Pearson of Compass]

RELATED:

Interior photos by Shannon Dupre; Exterior photo courtesy of Rise Media.

Get Inspired by NYC.

You May Also Like